Free Newsletter
Consolidated iPhone 3G lawsuits head to Apple’s backyard
Free newsletter via e-mail
Tools
A panel of federal judges consolidated a dozen lawsuits alleging performance problems and misleading marketing in Apple's iPhone 3G. According to ComputerWorld, the panel combined them into one action that will be heard in San Francisco--near Apple's headquarters. The move brings the issue one step closer to class-action status, which could potentially cover millions of iPhone 3G owners and give Apple lawyers a major headache.
The U.S. Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation, which comprises seven judges and decides whether to combine similar lawsuits in separate districts, ruled that 12 different lawsuits from across the country be consolidated in the Northern District of California, which is based in San Francisco. The panel noted that Apple's headquarters are located in this district and "relevant witnesses and documents will likely be found there"--language implying Apple's iPhone designers may well be called on to defend the company's touchscreen cell phone.
The lawsuits involved in the ruling began trickling in shortly after the release last summer of Apple's 3G iPhone, alleging the device failed to adequately connect to AT&T's network and was slower than advertised. Apple released a series of software updates shortly after the device's debut, apparently aimed at addressing the problems, though the company never disclosed the specific reason for the updates.
Several of the now-combined lawsuits sought class-action status, and presumably the newly consolidated action will also. If the lawsuit becomes a class action, is could potentially cover millions of iPhone 3G owners.
Interestingly, the news comes just a few weeks after the release of the iPhone 3GS, which Apple said is significantly faster than last year's model and features an updated wireless connection.
For more:
- see this ComputerWorld article
Related Articles:
Apple releases iPhone 3G fix
Are design flaws plaguing the iPhone 3G?
Apple asks judge to toss out iPhone 3G lawsuit
Apple slammed with lawsuit over iPhone 3G
Apple, AT&T sued over iPhone 3G
More stories about touchscreen Performance Problems Misleading Marketing lawsuit iPhone Dozen Lawsuits Class Action Suit Apple
Comments
Posted by Mike Raphone | July 7, 2009 - 7:26pm
Doesn't Apple consider the iPhone a miracle? Well I mean a miracle if it works and a miracle if calls placed through it are not dropped by the AT&T Network. When will Apple begin installing an automatic fire extingushier in each 3GS?
Posted by Anonymous | July 7, 2009 - 7:38pm
They also claimed the life of the battery in the new 3GS is longer .. NOT!
When will this bring a formal complaint against them .. next year????
Posted by jared | July 8, 2009 - 9:38am
i think they have a case - i have coworkers with the iphone while i use nokia devices (N95 for 2 years and just upgraded to the N97). the iphone drops calls regularly while my nokia devices don't - over months of use in the same room i keep hearing my coworkers calling people back with, "sorry, at&t sucks". i'm on at&t right next to them and never have the issue here.
more than that, their bandwidth sucks on the iphone 3g - mobile speed tests regularly come up at around 300 kbps for them, while i typically get 900 kbps on my 3G N97. that's a 3 fold difference in devices claiming the exact same level of support for at&t.
i would hope at&t would be compensated for the inferred defamation of their network functionality: iphone owners all over the states tend to speak so overwhelmingly about at&t being the source of their problems, and apple has never properly addressed the issue. in the end, it is clearly a design flaw in the device and/or the 3g transceiver used.
-jared
Comments (3) | Post a comment