AT&T (NYSE:T) filed a response to the Department of Justice's Aug. 31 complaint seeking to block the company's proposed $39 billion acquisition of T-Mobile USA. In the filing, AT&T claims that the Justice Department fails to acknowledge the efficiencies that will result from the deal and doesn't accurately depict the amount of competition that exists in the wireless industry.
AT&T said that wireless competition remains fierce--prices are declining, innovation is occurring and new providers are entering the business. Specifically, the company pointed to competitors such as established providers Verizon Wireless (NYSE:VZ) and Sprint (NYSE:S), as well as firms such as MetroPCS (NASDAQ:PCS), and Leap/Cricket (NASDAQ:LEAP), which it called "upstarts." It also acknowledged regional players such as U.S. Cellular and Cellular South. Those claims echo ones AT&T has publicly made to the FCC over the deal.
AT&T also said that the Justice Department complaint does not explain how T-Mobile, which AT&T says has lost subscribers despite being in a robustly growing market, provides any unique competitive threat against AT&T. "Although the transaction will remove T-Mobile as an independent competitor, no significant consumer harm will result," AT&T said. F"or the past two years, T-Mobile has been losing customers, despite growing demand, and, without the spectrum to deploy a 4G LTE network."
The company also discounts the Justice Department's claims that T-Mobile is a "challenger brand" that offers disruptive pricing. AT&T instead says that T-Mobile's business model remains "stuck in the middle" between larger providers like Verizon, AT&T and Sprint and lower-priced competitors MetroPCS and Cricket.
AT&T also reiterated its prior claims that without the merger, it will continue to experience capacity constraints, and millions of customers will be deprived of faster and higher quality service.
In a statement that accompanied the filing, AT&T said it is seeking an expedited hearing on the matter and that it remains open to finding a solution to the DOJ's problems with the T-Mobile merger.
The company and the DOJ are scheduled to present their case to U.S. District Court Judge Ellen Huvelle during a hearing on Sept. 21. Sprint filed its own lawsuit against the deal and that lawsuit is also expected to be heard by Huvelle.
- see this AT&T Filing
- see this CNET article
AT&T, DOJ ordered to come up with settlement plans by Sept. 21
Sprint sues to block AT&T/T-Mobile deal
Deutsche Telekom: We're open to conditions on AT&T/T-Mobile deal
Where does T-Mobile go from here for 4G?
Report: AT&T hires bank to explore $8B in asset sales on T-Mobile deal
Entner: Without AT&T, T-Mobile will be left to a slow death
Department of Justice sues to block AT&T/T-Mobile deal