AT&T knocks down T-Mobile's arguments against its 700 MHz deal with Appalachian Wireless

AT&T Mobility (NYSE: T) said the FCC should approve its purchase of 700 MHz spectrum from East Kentucky Network, which does business as Appalachian Wireless, and that T-Mobile US' (NYSE:TMUS) petition to block the deal is groundless.

Last month AT&T asked the FCC to approve its purchase of three Lower 700 MHz C Block licenses from East Kentucky Network. AT&T would be assigned 12 MHz of Lower 700 MHz C Block spectrum in 20 counties covering all of three cellular market areas (Huntington-Ashland, which touches all three states, and Lexington-Fayette and Madison in Kentucky). Post-transaction, AT&T would hold 113 to 145 MHz of spectrum in total, and 43 to 55 MHz of below-1-GHz spectrum, in the three CMAs.

In May 2014 the FCC approved new rules that said transactions resulting in a carrier gaining control of one-third of the spectrum below 1 GHz in a given market--which equates to roughly 45 MHz of low-band spectrum--"will be subject to enhanced review" in the FCC's case-by-case competitive evaluation of spectrum deals.

T-Mobile has been arguing that Verizon Wireless (NYSE: VZ) and AT&T already have too much low-band spectrum, and that the FCC should increase the size of the spectrum reserve in next year's incentive auction of 600 MHz airwaves to level the playing field. T-Mobile appears on its way to lose that regulatory battle.

"The Commission, meanwhile, must enforce its well-reasoned 'enhanced factor' analysis in a manner that meaningfully protects consumers against the increased market position that this transaction would allow AT&T to achieve," T-Mobile wrote in its filing last month to the FCC, asking the FCC to block the deal.

AT&T argued that T-Mobile's petition is missing the point. "This is a spectrum-only transaction. The transaction will not eliminate any competitors in these markets or diminish any other carrier's ability to respond to AT&T," AT&T wrote in its filing. "The spectrum is currently lying fallow, as EKN has not deployed this spectrum and has no plans to do so. AT&T will not only use that spectrum to deploy a cutting-edge LTE network, it can pair this spectrum with adjacent spectrum to increase its current 5x5 MHz deployments to a more spectrally efficient 10x10 MHz LTE deployment."

The FCC "has repeatedly and consistently held that transactions with these characteristics strengthen competition and provide strong public interest benefits," AT&T wrote.

"Although T-Mobile seems to think that any acquisition of spectrum below 1 GHz triggering the 'enhanced factor' test is per se anticompetitive, the Commission has made clear that enhanced factor review is merely a component of, and does not replace, the Commission's case-by-case review," of spectrum transactions," AT&T wrote. "Indeed, T-Mobile does not even cite the one case in which the Commission has actually applied 'enhanced factor' review to market-specific facts--the recent AT&T/Plateau Order--but that case confirms that the overarching question always remains simply whether the potential for competitive harms outweighs the public interest benefits of the transaction."

AT&T wrote that the FCC has held that where the potential for competitive harm is low, "the acquisition of below-1-GHz spectrum resulting in holdings of approximately one-third or more would not preclude a conclusion that a proposed transaction, on balance, furthers the public interest."

Thus, AT&T argues, "under the correct 'enhanced review' standard, as articulated and applied in the AT&T/Plateau Order, the proposed transactions raise no substantial issues and can be quickly approved."

For more:
- see this AT&T FCC filing

Related articles:
Wheeler shoots down T-Mobile's push for 40 MHz spectrum reserve in 600 MHz auction
T-Mobile's quest for larger 600 MHz reserve gets boost from DOJ
T-Mobile wants FCC to block AT&T's 700 MHz purchases as 600 MHz auction looms
AT&T hunts for 700 MHz spectrum in Kentucky, Ohio and West Virginia
AT&T: T-Mobile's 600 MHz reserve strategy is about protecting urban markets, not expanding rural coverage

Suggested Articles

Application developers will benefit from the efficiency of using Verizon’s distributed network coupled with its fiber footprint and backbone.

American Tower thinks open RAN architecture could be a positive, but it won’t change tower economics or necessarily mean new customers.

Company says virtualized network provides better coverage with fewer base stations.